Free live session, Wed 25 Nov, 17:00 Malta time.Save your seat

Skip to content
← Back to Bytes

By Stephen Ellul, founder of Growth Bully

Winning an RFP Is Decided Before the Document Arrives

Most advice on how to win an RFP starts at the response document. The tenders you actually win were decided months earlier, by who the panel already knew.

Winning an RFP Is Decided Before the Document Arrives
Key takeaways
  • You win an RFP by being known to the evaluation panel before the specification is written, and by refusing most of the tenders you are sent.
  • The response document decides very little.
  • Spend the hours on a bid or no bid test, on familiarity with a named list of buyers, and on the response last.

Every guide to winning an RFP begins at the same moment: the document has landed, the deadline is three weeks out, and the question is how to write a stronger response. At Growth Bully, a Malta performance marketing agency, the tenders our clients win rarely turn on that document. They turn on whether the people scoring it had heard of the bidder before the specification existed. Which means most of the work is marketing work, and it happens months earlier.

Should you bid on this RFP at all?

Usually not. A serious bid costs real senior hours, and the base rate on a cold tender is poor enough that those hours almost always pay better spent warming up two buyers you could reach directly. So the first job is a bid or no bid test, run before anyone opens the template.

Five questions decide it:

  1. Did anyone from the buying organisation speak to you before this was published? If not, you are reading a specification that someone else helped shape.
  2. Can you name who will score it, and what they are measured on? If the panel is anonymous to you, your response is being judged on criteria you are guessing at.
  3. Does the specification describe how you work, or how somebody else works? Requirements are written from somebody's way of delivering. Read whose.
  4. Is an incumbent being retendered? A retender with a satisfied incumbent is usually a procurement formality, and your response is making up the required number of bidders.
  5. Could you deliver this at full margin without reorganising the business? Winning work you cannot profitably do is worse than losing it.

Three noes and you decline, politely and in writing, with a line about what you would need in order to bid next time. That letter is read by a human, and it is the cheapest introduction you will ever make to a buyer who is now expecting to hear from you again.

What is actually being decided before the document arrives?

The shortlist, and usually the preference inside it. A specification is almost never written in isolation. It is shaped in conversations with one or two suppliers the buyer already trusted enough to ask, and those conversations set the scope, the weightings and the vocabulary the whole field will then answer in.

This is why the familiar bidder wins so often without having written anything better. They are not scoring higher on persuasion, they are scoring higher on a document whose questions they have already heard in a meeting. The people who shape it are rarely the ones who sign it either, which is the distinction in our piece on the decision maker, the champion and the economic buyer. The champion drafts, the panel scores, the economic buyer approves, and your name needs to be credible to all three before the file opens.

How do you get known by the evaluators months in advance?

By being visible to a named list rather than to a market. Pick the twenty to fifty organisations that tender for what you sell, identify the three roles that typically sit on their panels, and make sure something useful from you reaches those roles every month for a year. That is a small, boring, entirely doable campaign.

In practice it is five things, in rough order of how much they move a panel:

  • A reference the panel can phone. One client in their sector who will take a call is worth more than every page of your methodology section.
  • Published work that answers the question their specification will ask. If you want to win tenders about reporting, publish how you report before anyone asks.
  • Paid reach aimed at a named account list. Not a broad awareness campaign. The same few hundred people, seeing your name in a useful context, repeatedly.
  • One real meeting a year with each target organisation, while nothing is being tendered and you are not selling anything.
  • Presence where their sector talks to itself. The association event, the industry panel, the trade publication they actually read.

None of this is fast, which is the point. The mechanics of reaching those roles at all are in how to reach B2B decision makers, and running it as a standing system rather than a scramble is what our Decision-Maker Pipeline exists to do.

What does a strong response do that a compliant one does not?

It answers in the buyer's words and it removes risk. A compliant response proves you can do the work. A winning one makes the panel feel safe choosing you, which is a different job, because nobody on an evaluation panel is rewarded for a brave decision and everybody remembers a bad one.

Concretely, that means mirroring the specification's own vocabulary rather than your internal names for things, so a scorer can find each answer where they expect it. It means naming the people who will do the work and what else is on their desks. It means stating the two things most likely to go wrong and what you do when they do, because every panel knows something will. And it means justifying the price with scope and outcomes instead of defending it, so the cheapest bid is not the only one with a story.

How do you calculate an RFP win rate worth tracking?

Wins divided by submissions, measured over a period long enough to hold at least ten submissions, then split by whether you had contact with the buyer before publication. One blended number tells you nothing you can act on. The split tells you whether to bid more or to market earlier.

Track two more things beside it. Your no bid rate, because a team that bids on everything is a team with no qualification and a low win rate by arithmetic. And the senior hours each bid consumes, which is the real cost and the number that makes declining feel like a decision rather than a failure. Tender cycles are long, so give any change a full cycle before you read it, as in how long a B2B sales cycle really runs.

When should you stop bidding and do something else?

When you have submitted ten cold bids without a win. At that point the evidence is not that your documents are weak, it is that you are entering competitions already decided. The fix is not a better template. It is twelve months of being known to a short list of buyers before their next specification is drafted.

That is the uncomfortable version of the answer, and it is also the one that compounds. Bids are won or lost in a fortnight and leave nothing behind. Familiarity with thirty named buyers keeps paying on every tender they publish for years, and it shortens the ones you do win. If you would rather be the supplier the next specification gets written around, tell us who tenders for what you sell and we will build the pipeline that reaches them.

Want more of this in your Google results? Add us as a preferred source.Add Growth Bully on Google
Questions

The honest answers.

Is it worth responding to an RFP from an organisation that has never heard of you?

Rarely, unless the evaluation is purely mechanical, such as a price only framework or a fully scored public procurement where the criteria are published and objective. In a tender with any qualitative weighting, a cold bidder is competing against suppliers who helped shape the questions. Decline in writing, state what you would need to bid next time, and start the familiarity work instead.

What is a good RFP win rate?

There is no credible universal benchmark, and the figures that circulate online rarely carry a dated source or a definition of what counted as a submission. The useful comparison is internal: your win rate on tenders where you had contact before publication, against your win rate on cold ones. If the second is not far lower, your qualification is probably too loose.

How long does it take before the familiarity work starts winning tenders?

A full tender cycle, which in most sectors means nine to eighteen months before the effect is visible, because you cannot win a specification that was already drafted when you started. The earlier signals arrive sooner: buyers replying, being asked for an informal view while scope is being set, and being invited to tender rather than finding the notice yourself.

Who should actually write the response document?

Whoever will deliver the work, edited by one person who owns the whole document. Responses assembled from a library of previous answers read as assembled, and panels notice when section four describes a different company from section seven. The delivery lead supplies substance, the editor supplies the voice and checks every question is answered where the scorer expects it.

Can marketing help with public tenders where the scoring is fixed?

Yes, in two ways that do not touch the scoring. It gets you on the invitation and alert lists so you see notices early enough to prepare properly rather than in the final week. And it builds the published work and references your quality answers point to, since fixed scoring still asks for evidence of relevant delivery, and that evidence has to exist before the notice appears.

Put it to work

Your version of this, in 30 minutes.

Stephen looks at your account with you and tells you what he would fix first. No pitch, no deck.

30 minutes with Stephen. Leave with a plan.

Book a 30-minute call with Stephen